Troubleshooting Proxy Issues in Visual Basic 6 Applications

Proxy Patterns and COM Interop in Visual Basic 6Visual Basic 6 (VB6) remains in use in legacy environments across enterprises and embedded applications. When modernizing, integrating, or maintaining VB6 systems, developers often face interoperability challenges between VB6’s COM-based architecture and other components—native DLLs, .NET assemblies, remote services, or different process boundaries. Proxy patterns provide a structured way to manage those interactions, encapsulate communication details, and make COM interop safer, more maintainable, and easier to test.

This article explains proxy patterns relevant to VB6, how COM interop works in VB6, common scenarios and problems, and practical design and implementation guidance—including code examples, deployment considerations, and troubleshooting tips.

---

Table of contents

1. Background: COM, VB6, and interop basics
2. What is a proxy pattern? Types relevant to VB6
3. Common COM interop scenarios in VB6
4. Designing proxies for VB6: goals and constraints
5. Implementation examples
   • Local interface proxy (wrapper)
   • Out-of-process/stub proxy for cross-process COM
   • Remoting-style proxy to talk to .NET components
6. Deployment and registration issues (DLLs, Type Libraries, registry)
7. Performance, threading, and marshaling concerns
8. Testing and debugging strategies
9. Migration and modernization considerations
10. Summary

---

1. Background: COM, VB6, and interop basics

COM (Component Object Model) is the binary-interface standard that VB6 uses for objects, libraries, and cross-process integration. VB6 consumes COM objects via references to Type Libraries (.tlb) or by late binding using CreateObject/GetObject.

Key VB6/COM facts:

• VB6 is COM-native: VB6 classes and ActiveX EXEs/DLLs are exposed as COM components.
• Type Libraries describe COM interfaces and make early binding (compile-time method/constant checking) possible.
• Marshaling moves parameters and return values across apartment/process boundaries; COM provides standard marshaling for Automation-compatible types (BSTR, VARIANT, SAFEARRAY, IUnknown/IStream with proxies/stubs when necessary).

Understanding how COM marshals calls and what VB6 supports (automation-safe types, single/multi-threaded apartments) is essential for designing proxies that won’t break at runtime.

---

2. What is a proxy pattern? Types relevant to VB6

A proxy is an object that acts as an intermediary for another object. In the context of VB6 and COM interop, proxies hide communication details, provide a stable interface, handle marshaling, adapt incompatible interfaces, and constrain error handling.

Common proxy types used with VB6:

• Proxy/wrapper for API adaptation: wraps a COM object (or native DLL) to present a VB6-friendly interface and handle type conversions.
• Out-of-process proxy/stub: enables calls from VB6 in one process to a component in another process, often implemented as an ActiveX EXE or COM surrogate.
• Transparent proxy for remoting: delegates calls to remote services (HTTP/REST, sockets, or .NET remoting) while presenting a COM interface.
• Caching proxy: locally caches results from a COM server or remote service to reduce round-trips.
• Security/validation proxy: ensures calls meet security/validation rules before forwarding to protected components.

---

3. Common COM interop scenarios in VB6

Typical integration points where proxies help:

• VB6 talks to newer .NET services or assemblies.
• VB6 consumes native C/C++ DLL functionality that uses non-Automation types.
• Cross-process communication between VB6 client and server (separate EXE).
• Interfacing with web services or REST APIs where VB6 lacks native HTTP or JSON support.
• Adapting large or unstable third-party COM APIs to a stable internal VB6 interface.

Each scenario imposes constraints: marshaling types, threading model (STA vs MTA), and registration/installation complexities.

---

4. Designing proxies for VB6: goals and constraints

Goals:

• Hide marshaling, threading, and lifetime complexity.
• Present a simple Automation-friendly API to VB6 (BSTR, Long, Double, Boolean, SAFEARRAY, IDispatch/IDispatch-based interfaces).
• Fail gracefully with clear error handling (convert HRESULTs/COM errors into VB6 Err.Raise with meaningful codes/messages).
• Minimize changes to existing VB6 clients.

Constraints:

• VB6 works best with Automation-compatible types and IDispatch/dispinterfaces; custom vtable-only interfaces can be used but are harder to consume from VB6.
• COM registration (registry entries, ProgIDs, CLSIDs, typelib) is required for early-binding; late-binding (CreateObject) avoids compile-time refs but loses Intellisense and type safety.
• Threading: VB6 forms and controls must run in STA; worker threads and cross-apartment calls require careful marshaling and often an out-of-process server.

Design checklist:

• Define a clean, Automation-friendly interface for the proxy.
• Keep operations coarse-grained to reduce marshaling overhead.
• Provide synchronous and, when needed, asynchronous patterns (callbacks, events via connection points or polling).
• Centralize error translation and logging in the proxy layer.

---

5. Implementation examples

Note: VB6 code examples show how a client calls a proxy; proxy implementations can be VB6 ActiveX DLL/EXE, C++ COM, or a .NET COM-visible assembly.

5.1 Local interface proxy (VB6 wrapper for a C++ COM object)

Goal: adapt a native COM server with vtable interfaces or non-Automation types to a VB6-friendly IDispatch-based wrapper.

VB6 client-facing wrapper (VB6 ActiveX DLL):

' Class: ExampleWrapper (Implements IExampleWrapper) Private m_real As Object ' raw COM object Public Function Initialize() As Boolean     On Error GoTo ErrHandler     Set m_real = CreateObject("NativeServer.RealObject") ' or GetObject     Initialize = True     Exit Function ErrHandler:     Err.Raise Err.Number, "ExampleWrapper.Initialize", Err.Description End Function Public Function CalculateSum(a As Double, b As Double) As Double     On Error GoTo ErrHandler     CalculateSum = m_real.NativeAdd(CDbl(a), CDbl(b))     Exit Function ErrHandler:     Err.Raise Err.Number, "ExampleWrapper.CalculateSum", Err.Description End Function 

This wrapper converts types, centralizes error handling, and exposes methods VB6 can call easily.

5.2 Out-of-process proxy (ActiveX EXE) for cross-process isolation

Use an ActiveX EXE to host a COM server in its own process to avoid threading/memory conflicts and allow restartable servers.

Key points:

• Set the project to ActiveX EXE in VB6.
• Expose classes with PublicNotCreatable or remoteable attributes if needed.
• VB6 clients use CreateObject with the server’s ProgID; COM ensures a proxy/stub relationship across process boundaries.

Example client:

Dim srv As Object Set srv = CreateObject("MyServer.RemoteClass") ' ActiveX EXE server Dim result As Double result = srv.SomeMethod(1.2, 3.4) 

5.3 Remoting-style proxy to call .NET component or web service

Approach A — Use a COM-visible .NET assembly:

• Build a .NET assembly with [ComVisible(true)], register for COM interop (Regasm), and design methods to use Automation-safe types.
• VB6 calls the .NET object like any COM object.

Approach B — VB6 wrapper that translates to HTTP/JSON:

• Implement an ActiveX DLL in VB6 that uses WinINet/URLMon (or a small native helper) to call REST/JSON, parse responses (via a lightweight JSON parser or MSXML), and expose typed methods to VB6.

Example pattern (pseudo-code):

• Proxy receives VB6 call -> constructs HTTP request -> calls external service -> parse JSON -> return results as SAFEARRAY/strings/doubles.

---

6. Deployment and registration issues

COM components must be registered. Common steps:

• Register VB6 ActiveX DLL/EXE with regsvr32 (for inproc DLLs) or by running the EXE to self-register COM classes (ActiveX EXE).
• For .NET COM-visible assemblies, use Regasm /tlb to register and optionally create an installer.
• Ensure type library (.tlb) is installed and the client references it for early binding.
• Mind 32-bit vs 64-bit: VB6 is 32-bit, so COM servers consumed by VB6 must be registered in the 32-bit registry hive and be 32-bit processes. A 64-bit .NET assembly running in-process won’t work; use out-of-process or a 32-bit COM-visible shim.

Common pitfalls:

• Missing or wrong ProgID/CLSIDs in registry.
• Type library version mismatches causing binary incompatibility.
• DLL Hell: different versions installed side-by-side with incompatible type libs—use strong versioning and installers that update references.

---

7. Performance, threading, and marshaling concerns

Marshaling cost:

• Each cross-apartment or cross-process COM call has overhead. Reduce chattiness by batching data (use arrays/structures rather than many small calls).
• Use SAFEARRAYs or marshaled BLOBs for bulk data transfer.

Threading and apartments:

• VB6 UI runs in STA. If a COM server is MTA or uses worker threads, COM will marshal calls appropriately—but beware of deadlocks if the server synchronously calls back into the VB6 UI thread.
• Use connection points (events) cautiously: server must marshal event calls to the client’s apartment.

Long-running operations:

• Offload to background server (ActiveX EXE or external service) and provide progress via polling or events to avoid freezing VB6 UI.

Memory and lifetime:

• COM reference counting governs object lifetime. Release references (Set obj = Nothing) promptly to avoid leaks and allow servers to shut down.

---

8. Testing and debugging strategies

• Use OLE/COM Object Viewer to inspect type libraries and interfaces.
• Use Process Monitor and ProcMon to trace registry/LoadLibrary issues.
• Use DbgView and event logs for native components.
• For .NET interop, enable Fusion logging when assembly binding fails.
• Write unit tests around your proxy layer (mock the underlying component using a test double) so VB6 UI code is easier to test.
• Add verbose logging in the proxy for marshaled calls (parameters, HRESULTs, exceptions) to diagnose failures in production.

---

9. Migration and modernization considerations

If you plan to move away from VB6 or modernize:

• Use proxies as an anti-corruption layer: keep legacy VB6 code unchanged while the proxy adapts it to newer backends (.NET, microservices).
• Consider exposing a minimal COM surface and put complex logic in modern services behind that surface.
• For large migrations, wrap legacy systems with stable COM shims and incrementally replace backend implementations.
• Evaluate rewriting performance-sensitive parts in native C++ COM components or moving UI to .NET with COM interop bridges.

---

10. Summary

• Proxies decouple VB6 clients from implementation details: they adapt interfaces, manage marshaling, centralize error handling, and provide cross-process isolation.
• Design proxies with Automation-friendly types, coarse-grained methods, and clear error translation.
• Watch deployment, registration, threading, and marshaling pitfalls—VB6 is 32-bit and STA-bound.
• Use proxies as a pragmatic modernization tool to gradually replace or rehost legacy VB6 functionality.

If you want, I can:

• Provide a complete VB6 ActiveX DLL example that wraps a specific native COM interface you’re working with.
• Draft a migration plan for replacing parts of your VB6 app with a .NET backend while keeping a COM proxy.